How real estate can avoid a ‘pink boot’ data problem
Holding back listings won't make anyone stand out, leaders say, and copying MLS data into vendor systems has to stop.
Key points:
- At the Edge Tech and Data Forum, MLS and tech leaders compared real estate's shared data to the trend of World Cup players wearing pink cleats.
- Using the same data doesn’t necessarily lead to the same outcomes when players embrace their unique strengths, however.
- NorthstarMLS CEO Tim Dain said the industry needs more transparency and less data replication, which may be an “uncomfortable” shift for some brokers and vendors.
Data is driving more decisions than people might realize, from traffic light timing to the pink shoes that made a splash at one of the world's most popular sporting events — which is why a gathering of real estate MLS, tech and brokerage leaders ended up talking about soccer at the Edge Tech and Data Forum in Dallas last month.
The pink cleats, in case you are not one for whom "futbol is life," were seen on the feet of many players across teams and brands participating in the World Cup. It wasn't some shared plan, but rather shared data that created this colorful moment.
"They all drew the same conclusions and got to the same place where most of them even had the same shade of pink," said Jack Miller, president and CEO of real estate consultancy T3 Sixty, which put on the event in partnership with its independent news division, Real Estate News.
Messing with the playing field isn't the answer
Residential real estate has its own version of the pink-boots problem: Everyone works from the same MLS data and everyone wants to stand out. The temptation for a brokerage is to create differentiation by holding back data, and that's where disputes over private listings come in.
Jessie Edgerton, CEO of the Council of Multiple Listing Services, said messing with the playing field can hurt the game.
"The way to solve the pink-boots problem is not to go out onto the turf and scoop out large portions of the turf and try to make another turf," she said. "It's going to ruin the fricking game. So stop scooping out."
And even with shared data, there is a way to differentiate, said Kevin Greene, senior vice president and GM of real estate solutions at Cotality. Weather forecasters have shared data too, but "are their forecasts the same? No, not at all," Greene said. Real estate agents have access to the same data through their MLS system and their platform, yet CMAs and pricing are different. "That's the big part: Having that local knowledge and being able to interpret the data."
From widespread copying to controlled access
NorthstarMLS CEO Tim Dain, meanwhile, said something else needs to stop: data replication.
Today many vendors copy MLS data into their own systems and build products on top of it. Dain said MLSs need to "pivot to non-replication," with the MLS or brokerage acting as the infrastructure and vendors accessing data rather than storing it.
That would flip the relationship, he said. Instead of a vendor giving the MLS a service level agreement, the MLS would be giving one to the vendor. Replication agreements that remain would need to get tighter and be reviewed "by actual attorneys and by actual technologists," with audit rights enforced.
And it will be "uncomfortable" for some brokers: "They will want their vendor to be the special vendor that gets to replicate the data."
Dain also called for more transparency about the contracts that put listings in front of consumers. He wants agents to be able to see where their listing went and why. "How did my data get there? Who authorized it to be there? Under what terms is it displayed? Can I affect those terms?" he asked.
However the rules of the game may shift, Edgerton said listings should remain the shared foundation of the system with MLSs operating as "independent, powerful companies."