Most states bury agent discipline records, consumer group finds
Only two states earned a "good" rating in a Consumer Policy Center review of the state real estate commission licensing portals used by buyers and sellers.
Key points:
- A new report from the CPC concluded that nearly all state real estate commissions need to improve the online tools they advise consumers to use before hiring an agent.
- Disciplinary actions against agents were often missing or difficult to find, not explained clearly or handled through letters with no recipient names recorded online.
- One challenge is the lack of a nationwide database and different terminology among states; another is that even AI tools can’t access many of the records.
State real estate commissions are responsible for protecting consumers, and many advise buyers and sellers to look up an agent's license and any history of disciplinary actions before hiring them. But in most states, that search doesn't show whether the agent has been disciplined, or what for, according to a new report from the Consumer Policy Center.
The study, conducted by CPC Fellow Wendy Gilch, assessed how well real estate commissions actually serve consumers. Gilch searched each state's free online lookup system by plugging in the names of agents with known disciplinary records or recent criminal charges. She scored each state on three criteria: whether the action was easy to find, whether it was explained in plain language and whether the lookup showed the agent's past brokerages.
Of the 47 states that could be rated, two earned a "good" rating, 21 "need improvement" and 24 rated "poor." Sixteen states scored zero, meaning a consumer who checked the lookup "would have found no sign of the action, no document and no work history," the report said. Lookups in Kentucky, Washington and Wyoming yielded inconclusive results.
Illinois scored the highest, with seven of eight possible points, because it flags an action on a licensee's summary and explains it in plain language. Arizona earned six points for explaining actions and listing past brokerages, though consumers have to click into a profile and scroll to find them.
Hidden, confusing or missing information
Only three states flagged a disciplinary action in the first result a consumer sees for a given agent. In 27 more, consumers had to click or scroll, and in some cases they were required to download a PDF or legal document to see any actions.
Several states publish actions in newsletters or batched disciplinary pages but never connect them to the licensee's record, Gilch found, so a consumer who checks the lookup sees what appears to be a clean history. In other cases the lookup contradicted the record, showing no action for licensees the state had disciplined, and one state placed a green check mark next to "disciplinary action," which might leave consumers to believe there was no action taken or the agent had been cleared.
Only Arizona and California show an agent's work history, which is relevant because frequent moves between firms can signal problems with competence or client service, the report argues. States also lack a common vocabulary, with disciplinary actions sometimes labeled using vague terms like "orders," "case history" or "public documents."
Actions can remain invisible, even when crimes are involved
State real estate commissions can close a case with a private letter, even when a licensee broke the rules. Oregon's commission, for example, issued far more educational letters for minor violations than public actions in 2025. Those letters, which are expunged after six years, aren't considered disciplinary actions and recipients aren't named. The report argues that consumers should be able to decide for themselves whether a violation is minor.
Additionally, many states wait for a conviction or guilty plea before acting on felony charges, according to the report. That has allowed agents charged with serious crimes to remain licensed with clean records for months or even years. The report points to interim suspensions and the FBI's Rap Back fingerprint monitoring service as ways to act sooner.
50 disconnected systems — and AI isn't much help
Agents near state borders often hold licenses in multiple states, but there is no national lookup system for real estate agents. While ARELLO, the association of real estate regulators, operates a disciplinary database, it is not open to the public and currently has just 15 participating jurisdictions.
To see if AI could do a better job of surfacing information, Gilch used the chatbot Claude to run a search of the same licensees who were known to have been disciplined. In 34 of the 47 states, it found nothing, including in Illinois and Arizona, where records sit inside lookup tools that web searches can't open. Where Claude did find actions, they came from meeting minutes, PDF orders and newsletters rather than a page about the agent.
"The information was public, just not where commissions tell consumers to look," Gilch wrote.
The report includes nine recommendations for state commissions, including displaying actions on the main search results page using clear language, maintaining permanent searchable records for both actions and warnings, acting quickly on serious charges and publishing actions where search engines and AI tools can find them.