A ‘tough backdrop’ for mortgage rates as holiday slowdown begins
After four consecutive weeks of declines, the 30-year mortgage rate ticked up to 7.28% this week — and economists say more volatility is likely on the way.
Key points:
- The 30-year fixed-rate mortgage jumped to 7.28% this week, according to Freddie Mac, ending several consecutive weeks of declines.
- Economists say rate fluctuations are likely to continue in the coming weeks due in part to stock market volatility and the approaching fall and winter holidays.
- While home prices are mostly flat or slightly below the levels recorded this time last year, there are signs that incremental drops may occur soon.
The bumpy ride that mortgage rates have been on recently continued this week as economic uncertainty about artificial intelligence and inflation weighs on investors.
Mortgage rates jump after 4 weeks of declines
The 30-year fixed-rate mortgage averaged 7.28% as of Nov. 19, according to Freddie Mac's weekly survey, marking a significant jump from last week's 7.11% and snapping a four-week streak of falling rates. Mortgage News Daily (MND), which uses a different set of metrics in gauging rates, pegged the daily 30-year rate at 7.45% on Nov. 19 following higher rates recorded earlier this week.
"In general the 2nd half of November can be fairly random for rates due to idiosyncrasies associated with the holiday trading environment," MND COO Matthew Graham noted in a Nov. 18 online post.
Investors worried about AI, inflation
Stock market volatility may be contributing to that "fairly random" trend. While Anthropic had a record-breaking IPO on Nov. 19, investors appear to be concerned about AI in general, with stocks trading lower for much of this week. Meanwhile, tensions are rising in the ongoing U.S.-Iran war as more attacks occur in the Middle East, adding pressure to elevated inflation levels.
The likelihood of another short-term interest rate hike in December as the Federal Reserve attempts to tame inflation is also weighing on investors. As of midday Nov. 19, the CME Group's FedWatch tool was overwhelmingly forecasting a 25-basis-point bump and predicting about a 6% chance of a 50-basis-point increase when the Fed meets next month.
"That is a tough backdrop for mortgage rates heading into what is already a seasonally slow stretch for the housing market," said Anthony Smith, senior economist at Realtor.com.
What's happening with home prices?
Though elevated rates put existing and pending home sales in a deep freeze in October, there hasn't yet been a significant impact on home prices. Many real estate economists say median prices are either flat or slightly down in most markets — and it's unclear how long that will last.
Mike Simonsen, chief economist at Compass, said some incremental shifts may be occurring. In his weekly YouTube update, Simonsen noted that pending home sale prices are down 1.7% nationally compared to a year ago while MLS median sale prices have fallen 0.8% year-over-year.
Prices in some Midwestern cities "are falling the fastest," Simonsen said, noting that those areas had been holding national prices up because inventory there was tight. "There are some indicators of falling prices in the data now that haven't been in the data for several years."
While still higher than in recent years, Simonsen said the percentage of home price reductions is starting to decline. If that trend continues, it may be a sign that sellers are becoming more willing to pull their listing off the market than to lower their asking price.
"The easiest thing to overlook is that prices and sales volume can move differently," First American Chief Economist Mark Fleming said on a recent episode of the REconomy Podcast. "When both buyers and sellers pull back, there may be fewer transactions without much movement in prices."
Mortgage applications still falling
Overall mortgage application activity fell 2.3% week-over-week for the week ending Nov. 13, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA). Compared to a year ago, purchase applications have dropped 7%, while the refinance index has plummeted 54%.
Even rates for adjustable rate mortgages have risen in the past week, the MBA noted, dampening consumer enthusiasm for a loan product that is typically more popular when rates are rising.
Seasonal slowdown for new listings underway
Simonsen's data indicates that new listings are slowing significantly heading into the holiday season. However, since the slowdown in sales is keeping homes on the market longer, inventory has only dropped slightly from the previous week.
While recent Redfin data shows a similar drop-off for new listings, Redfin still shows overall inventory climbing slightly on a week-to-week basis. This slowdown of new listings is another indication that big price drops likely aren't coming quite yet.