A judge's gavel sits on a table beside the scales of justice
Shutterstock

Judge denies Compass' request for conference in MLS lawsuits 

The brokerage giant now has until Dec. 3 to file motions to dismiss or split up the complaints brought by nine MLSs in two lawsuits over pre-marketing rules.

November 19, 2026
4 mins

The federal judge overseeing two lawsuits targeting Compass has denied the brokerage's requests for a pre-motion conference.

Compass had sought the conference ahead of filing motions to either dismiss the cases, brought by a total of nine MLSs across the country, or separate the claims and transfer them to each MLS's home district.

The cases in question are CRMLS vs. Compass, filed Oct. 5 and amended Oct. 27 to add OneKey MLS as a plaintiff; and ARMLS vs. Compass, jointly filed Oct. 21 by the Arizona MLS alongside bridgeMLS, Canopy MLS, Doorify MLS, Hive MLS and REcolorado, and amended Oct. 30 to include MLSListings. All nine are asking the court to declare that their cooperation rules, which require brokers to submit publicly marketed listings to the MLS, don't violate antitrust laws.

What the judge had to say: In a terse order signed Thursday, U.S. District Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil of the Southern District of New York declined to adjust the briefing schedule and directed Compass to file its planned motions by Dec. 3.

The order follows a series of letters from attorneys for Compass and the MLSs, and in a footnote, Vyskocil told the parties to "refrain from filing seriatim updates on each and every development in this wide-ranging litigation."

Real Estate News has reached out to Compass for comment on the ruling.

Compass' rationale for dismissal or severance: In its Nov. 13 letter in the ARMLS case, Compass argued that the MLSs filed an improper preemptive lawsuit to beat the company to court after receiving demand letters from the brokerage in September. Compass claimed that several of the MLSs asked for deadline extensions, "signaling that a negotiated resolution was under consideration," but then used the extra time to prepare their own lawsuits.

Compass also argued that the MLSs adopted their rules independently, in different markets, so each MLS's claims should be split off and sent to its home district, just as Compass filed its own separate lawsuits against 15 MLSs on Nov. 12.

The MLSs' response: ARMLS and its co-plaintiffs pushed back in a letter filed Nov. 18, arguing that Compass' demand letters gave no indication of when or where it would sue, and that the day after the MLSs filed their complaint, Compass told the court it had "not decided whether to file any other cases." They also disputed the suggestion that negotiations were taking place, saying Compass made it clear there was no room for compromise.

The MLSs noted that they sued Compass in its home district, New York, where Compass filed its own lawsuit against Zillow, despite Zillow being headquartered in Seattle. Splitting up the case would be inefficient, they said, noting that Compass filed 15 lawsuits in 11 districts, including against three MLSs that never received a demand letter, according to the plaintiffs' counsel: Bay East, Contra Costa and NorthstarMLS.

In a news release about the letter's filing, ARMLS CEO Jeff Bosch added that "Compass's effort to scatter this dispute across multiple courts would create unnecessary complexity and expense without changing the fundamental issue at stake."

"We are defending cooperation rules that promote fair competition, give buyers broader access to available homes, and help sellers reach more potential buyers," Bosch asserted. "We believe these rules are lawful and procompetitive, and we look forward to defending them in court."

A familiar strategy: Compass made very similar arguments in a letter previously filed in the CRMLS case, where it asked the court to dismiss the complaint or send CRMLS' claims to California. Compass also argued that OneKey, which is based on Long Island, joined the case only after Compass sought the transfer, as a way to create a New York connection.

CRMLS and OneKey countered that Compass sent them nearly identical demand letters on the same day, with the same deadline. That makes the dispute a single campaign that belongs in one court, they asserted.

Get the latest real estate news delivered to your inbox.