The Zillow logo appears over a palm tree-lined street in West Covina, California
Illustration by Real Estate News/Shutterstock

Advocacy groups target Zillow in letter to California officials 

The consumer organizations called out Zillow’s market dominance, alleged steering and Preferred program as worthy of investigation or even legal action.

November 17, 2026
5 mins

Key points:

  • A letter from the Consumer Federation of America and others claims that Zillow’s Preview program and rental listings syndication reduce competition in the market.
  • It also cites allegations that Zillow incentivizes agents to steer buyers to its mortgage platform and questions Zillow’s cut of Preferred agent commissions.
  • The consumer groups urged California’s real estate commissioner and its business and consumer services agency secretary to investigate the concerns raised in the letter.

In recent months, advocacy groups and politicians have urged regulators and lawmakers to take a closer look at the real estate industry, citing concerns over practices that may harm consumers and further erode housing affordability. 

A September letter from 19 organizations, including the Consumer Federation of America (CFA), called upon the National Association of Attorneys General to "take up housing market integrity as a coordinated enforcement policy" and launch investigations into Zillow and Compass. That was followed in October by a letter to the Federal Trade Commission from two Democratic senators who urged the agency to look into potentially anticompetitive real estate practices such as private listing networks and mortgage referrals.

Now, a new letter co-authored by the CFA, Demand Progress Education Fund, Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund, Children's Advocacy Alliance and Revolving Door Project takes aim at one specific target: Zillow. 

In a written plea to California Department of Real Estate Commissioner Chika Sunquist and California Business and Consumer Services Agency Secretary Rohit Chopra, the organizations claim that Zillow's business practices are distorting the market "to its own profit and to the detriment of the public," and that the state agencies should act to "rein" Zillow in. HousingWire was first to report the news.

Listings dominance

The advocacy groups pointed to Zillow's exclusive agreements with more than 400 brokerages under its Preview program as proof of its dominance in the market. Zillow's move to extend Preview listings to Realtor.com also served to leave "competing platforms shut out of the freshest inventory," the letter claims.

Additionally, Zillow's "exclusive access" to inventory allows the portal to monetize listings, the letter argues. Through the company's Preferred agent program, Zillow can earn up to 40% of the buyers agent commission, "removing any incentive to compete on price," according to the letter. 

Meanwhile, Zillow's policy of paying listing agents 10% of the buy-side commission from sales closed through Preview listing leads could encourage agents to "simply park listings on Preview in hopes of collecting commissions on other sales," the letter states. The advocacy groups also allege that the 10% payment — set "unilaterally" by Zillow — violates "the spirit and possibly the letter" of NAR's 2024 commissions settlement.

"The Zillow Preferred Agent is essentially an interloper paying Zillow to execute a man-in-the-middle attack," the letter asserts. "This has triggered class-action litigation that includes RICO claims, alleging that Zillow and the participating brokerages meet the definition of a criminal enterprise." 

Notably, the case cited by the advocacy groups was amended in August to remove the RICO claims.

Lending, rentals programs risk consumer harm

The third prong of Zillow's market dominance is its mortgage lending program, the letter argues, whereby "Zillow coerces its affiliated buyer agents to steer consumers toward Zillow Home Loans, on pain of losing leads or expulsion from the Flex program."

The letter cited a paper by Georgetown University Law Center Professor of Economics Steven C. Salop — though the study, which was funded by CoStar, has been challenged by Zillow and by Salop's own consulting firm.

In the unpublished paper, Salop asserts that Zillow Home Loans borrowers pay "significantly higher mortgage costs" — an average of $4,600 more — than they would to other lenders. For the 72% of buyers who only submit one mortgage application (according to Zillow's own Consumer Housing Trends Report 2026), not shopping around could cost them, the advocacy groups argue. 

Zillow's efforts to grow its rental business "by attempting to place its own listings in front of renters and block their access to those of competitors" also poses a risk to consumers, the letter states. As evidence, it points to Zillow's rental syndication deal with Redfin, which prompted a lawsuit from the FTC and five states last year that was resolved in August. The settlement, which allows the syndication agreement to continue until 2030, "is far less than California consumers deserve," the advocacy groups said.

A call for investigation

The letter closed with a recommendation to the California Department of Real Estate to investigate Zillow for potential steering violations, its exclusive Preview agreements with brokerages and Realtor.com, and its alleged "re-coupling of commissions after the NAR settlement." 

The groups further recommended legal enforcement actions for what it characterized as Zillow's misleading "contact agent" and "request a tour" buttons, which they called a "deliberate consumer deception" since the user is sent to a partner agent, not the property's listing agent.

They also suggested the department "coordinate with the multistate coalition that brought the Redfin action so that Zillow cannot exploit jurisdictional gaps between state enforcers."

Zillow's stance

A Zillow spokesperson said in an email to Real Estate News that its Preview listings are not particularly exclusive, given that they are public and available for anyone to see, while adding that broader issues of hidden listings "deserve further scrutiny."

In response to the lawsuits cited in the letter, the spokesperson noted that the FTC/Redfin settlement helped maintain a "pro-consumer and procompetitive" partnership between Zillow and Redfin, and as for the steering claims, they pointed out that the Taylor case, which covered such issues, was dismissed by the court in July. The plaintiffs have since filed an amended, narrower complaint, which Zillow has again lobbied to dismiss. 

Get the latest real estate news delivered to your inbox.