Buyer sues Howard Hanna over ‘cash grab’ transaction fee
The plaintiff alleges the $395 fee ate up more than half of the funds she brought to the closing table. Howard Hanna says its practices comply with the law.
Lawsuits taking aim at the practice of brokerages charging consumers fixed transaction fees are piling up.
Suits filed by the same law firms: On Nov. 10, first-time homebuyer Dena M. Bergamasco filed a complaint against Howard Hanna, the brokerage she hired to represent her, over a $395 "Realtor Transaction Fee" charged on top of the buyer-broker commission at the time of her October 2021 purchase of a home in Pittsburgh. Such fees are also known as administrative or broker fees.
The law firms representing Bergamasco are Bala Cynwyd, Pennsylvania-based Kopelowitz Ostrow P.A. and Washington, D.C.-based Kalielgold PLLC — the same firms representing homebuyer Gregory A. Deivert in a similar case filed last month against Keller Williams Elite.
'Supposed to be looking out for her': Like Deivert's lawsuit, Bergamasco's complaint, filed in the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County, alleges breach of fiduciary duty and violation of the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law.
The $395 fee was charged "for nothing," Bergamasco's complaint alleges: "The fee had no service behind it, no cost behind it, and no name that accurately describes it. It is money taken from a client by the broker who was supposed to be looking out for her."
Bergamasco purchased the $217,000 property with a federally insured mortgage loan of $213,069 and a second loan from the Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency of $10,850 and received a $7,300 seller credit toward her closing costs. She brought $788.95 in cash to closing — which means Howard Hanna's fee allegedly ate up more than half of her closing funds.
'Nothing left for $395 to buy': The fee was included in the closing disclosure "wedged" between third-party charges for a pest inspection fee and an owner's title insurance premium, the complaint alleges. "[T]he Transaction Fee is deceptively labeled and placed to obscure what it is: a cash grab," according to the filing.
The complaint alleges that Howard Hanna teaches its agents to include the fee in every buyer transaction and to tell buyers that the fee is mandatory and, "if pressed, that it is for 'paperwork,' 'processing,' or some similar administrative purpose." But Bergamasco's attorneys stress that the seller-paid commission had already compensated Howard Hanna for its services to Bergamasco and that Bergamasco paid for the remaining paperwork done by the settlement agent and title insurer at closing.
"There was nothing left for $395 to buy," the complaint says.
What Howard Hanna had to say: "Howard Hanna is committed to transparency in our client relationships, including the disclosure of brokerage compensation," the brokerage told Real Estate News in a statement. "Our practices comply with applicable law. We respect the legal process and will respond through the appropriate court proceedings."
Practice is 'not unique': The complaint acknowledges that Howard Hanna's practice of charging such a fee is "not unique" and alleges that brokerages nationwide "are engaged in a disturbing pattern of hiding and mislabeling the same junk fee under different names," including a $500 "Broker Fee" at Compass in Pennsylvania and various Keller Williams market centers that charge a $650 "Broker Fee", a $499 "Additional Broker Commission," a $395 "Compliance Fee" or a $595 "Selling Agent Broker Fee."
"The fact that the same fee bears a different name and a different amount at every brokerage that charges it is itself evidence that the fee is entirely made up and not reflective of any service actually provided: a fee that paid for an actual service would have a name that described the service and a price that reflected its cost," according to the complaint.
Suit seeks various damages, class-action status: Bergamasco is demanding a jury trial and seeking actual and compensatory damages, statutory damages, treble damages, punitive damages, disgorgement of all fees collected, attorney fees and costs, pre-judgement and post-judgment interest, and a permanent injunction barring the defendant from charging the fee.
The suit seeks class-action status on behalf of all buyers "who, during the fullest period allowed by law," were represented by Howard Hanna in the purchase of a home in Pennsylvania and paid Howard Hanna "at closing, a flat-dollar 'Transaction Fee,' 'Realtor Transaction Fee,' or similar fixed fee in addition to a percentage-based commission," in a transaction in which Howard Hanna was also paid by the seller or the seller's broker. The complaint estimates Howard Hanna represents "thousands" of buyers each year.